Thursday, April 14, 2016

Chaplains, Decisions & the Most 'Alone' of Patients

By Paul C. McLean, April 14, 2016

In making decisions about medical treatment for patients who are “incapacitated and alone,” as an influential American Bar Association study once described them, there is a tension among medical judgment, ethics and the law that may be necessary but can do harm to a patient’s best interests. 

A judge’s comment from a 2015 California Superior Court ruling captures this tension well: “The court acknowledges that this order will likely create problems in how many skilled nursing facilities currently operate. ...  The court has considered this burden and weighed it against the due process concerns, and finds that the due process rights of these patients is more compelling. The stakes are simply too high to hold otherwise.” 

In other words, however justifiable, consideration of best interests of these patients and the medical judgment of those directly caring for them carried less weight than due process rights. This is a set-up for medical indecision, poor care and moral distress among caregivers.

The patient and care team alike deserve better. And so the question becomes, is it possible that patient best interests, the ethical principle of respect for persons, and the legal guarantee of due process might each be honored? If so, how?

In an imperfect system, the best process increasingly is seen to be a multidisciplinary decision-making committee within the institution, working from clear policy guidelines and including members of the institutional ethics committee.

The Community Ethics Committee, of which I am a longtime member, has just completed its report on Medical Decision-Making for Unknown & Unrepresented Patients, submitting it to the ethics leadership of Harvard Medical School and posting it on this website (see PUBLICATIONS). 

For the first time, I’ve felt it necessary to take serious issue with a CEC report. CEC reports always reflect a group “voice,” and individual differences are not unusual. This time, I see too much difference between the group voice and my own.

The first difference is fairly trivial. Early in this study, I was in the minority in deciding what to call this class of patients. The CEC opted for Unknown & Unrepresented. I preferred, and still do, the designation Unbefriended, for a patient who not only lacks capacity and the voice of an informed, caring, unbiased surrogate, but has no constituency calling attention to the patient’s plight. 

This point is significant because this patient’s strongest advocates, often their sole advocates, are by default the medical team providing care. But in making medical decisions, something crucial is missing: the patient’s values. Without them, it is easy for bias to cloud medical judgement — sometimes concerning decisions about withholding or withdrawing life-sustaining treatments.

The patient is at the mercy of the care team, and the care team is compromised and in many cases experiencing moral distress, which affects more than one patient. The patient deserves better, as does the care team.

I commend the CEC, and in particular our chair and report author Carol Powers, for both recognizing and drawing attention to the invaluable contribution of hospital chaplains in the medical decision-making process for a patient whose wishes and values are a mystery, and who has no one to speak for them. 

This is especially true when treatment decisions must be made inside the institution —  in some cases, “off the radar.” 

A properly trained chaplain can perhaps uniquely advocate for the patient’s values and best interests as well as play a key role in building understanding and confidence in a process prone to public suspicion and distrust — especially in circumstances when limited availability of resources might influence, or be seen to influence, the treatment decision.

In nursing homes, critical care units and other institutions caring for the extremely vulnerable, such pressure on treatment decisions is increasing midway through a 30-year doubling of the nation’s elderly population; Unknown & Unrepresented (or Unbefriended) Patients have scared off or outlived loved ones, and ethical quandaries about their best interests are increasingly common, as are the stresses placed on care providers. Again, both deserve better.

As the CEC has discovered, chaplains play essential roles in medical decision-making processes in San Diego, Memphis and elsewhere. 

However, in elevating the chaplain’s role, the CEC seems to render existing, multidisciplinary institutional ethics committees — often consisting of physicians, nurses, ethicists, psychologists, social workers, lawyers, and community members — almost irrelevant to the process.

I believe this is a mistake, diminishes the recommendation, and potentially harms the CEC’s unique, important and well-earned voice.

The diverse perspectives of a multidisciplinary ethics committee, including chaplains, provide an effective, arguably unique counterbalance to physician bias in a way no single discipline can.

As discussed in this new report, the CEC learned a lesson from its earlier study of decision-making in cases of medical futility. At that time, the CEC recommended creation of an external, quasi-judicial decision-making panel. 

Impressed in particular with the work of the Consent & Capacity Board in Ontario, Canada, I advocated for that model. But as an idea that would require funding and training without much of a constituency to promote it, it was not a practical recommendation in times of austerity. 

Similarly, there is a history of state, local and national groups studying the plight of Unknown & Unrepresented Patients and recommending investment in public guardianship sufficient to meet the need. These recommendations rarely are adequately acted upon. 

Despite clear, expert guidance from multiple studies, too little has changed — except the patient population, which continues to increase. One troubling study showed that incapacitated patients without representatives remain in critical care up to 50 percent longer than similar patients who are represented, an indication of indecision that serves no one’s best interests.

And so the CEC is wise both to endorse the concept of an internal decision-making team, and to attend to the pressing need for public buy-in for such an idea. Elevating the role of chaplains can play an important part. 

An internal decision-making team can be responsive, efficient, accountable, and make decisions focused on the patient and grounded in moral/ethical principles. 

But the best of these internal decision-making teams are by design multidisciplinary, and the CEC seems to have overlooked this.
Two models worth further attention are found in New York (supported by statute, notably) and the Department of Veterans Affairs. Both set clear and accountable policy for medical decision-making within the institution and allow for judicial recourse as needed. 

Essentially, they establish and require a systemic form of due process within the institution, which is crucial for a vulnerable patient who can express neither agreement nor disagreement with care decisions, and whose perceived interests can become lost in a devotion to due process.

There is no perfect solution to this decision-making quandary, and with adequate funding, public guardianship as an extension of the judicial process might well be the ideal. But society’s track record of adequately supporting this with funding and training is not promising.

There also is a certain irony to something missing from the CEC’s report — any mention or recommendation of a role to be played by community members — patients and families included.

These morally and ethically complex decisions require public awareness, buy-in and participation if they are to respect both individual patients and the larger society at whose mercy the patients find themselves. 

As several CEC members know from personal experience, community members increasingly are valued participants on hospital ethics committees. So who better to advise on the community’s role in medical decision-making for an incapacitated, vulnerable community member than a group long dedicated to giving the community a voice in the bioethics dialogue? 

Perhaps this is for CEC consideration, and membership growth, in the future.

I again commend the CEC, and our chair, Carol Powers, for advocating for a vulnerable and marginalized patient, for seeing the wisdom of an empowered decision-making process within the institution, and for validating the role of chaplain.

The CEC is unique in its structure and purpose, its volunteer participants are admirably dedicated to challenging, consequential work, and the teaching hospitals and ethics leadership of Harvard Medical School have been visionary in seeing the value of such a group voice.

Amid the medical profession’s need for public buy-in, the CEC is a model that merits adoption elsewhere.

62 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Phòng khám phụ khoa Thiên Hòa chuyên chữa trị các loại bệnh Vô sinh nữ, Rối loạn kinh nguyệt, đồng thời còn thực hiện chữa trị cac bệnh về Viêm lộ tuyến cổ tử cung hoặc Khí hư ra nhiều, hơn thế nữa còn thăm Khám phụ khoa. Mục bệnh xã hội bạn có thể đến điều trị các hạng mục bệnh như Bệnh giang mai, Bệnh lậu hoặc Bệnh sùi mào gà, thậm chí là các bệnh nguy hiểm hơn như Mụn rộp sinh dục, Bệnh chlamydia hoặc bệnh Rận mu. Nếu có dấu hiệu bệnh nên đi thăm khám và điều trị ngay lập tức. Nay còn bổ sung thêm các hạng mục Kinh nguyệt màu đen, Rong kinh và nhóm bệnh viêm nhiễm như Viêm âm đạo.

    ReplyDelete
  7. We are living in an age of technology but unfortunately our people have no knowledge about the use technology. Therefore, they should learn technical custom essay reviews because in this way they will be made useful things. Many institutions teach technical education in reasonable fees so we should don’t ignore technical education because that is not suitable for us.

    ReplyDelete

  8. Incredible post! Hello there , I know you did really well work, I respect your driving forward. Legal Steroids
    You have done really brilliant workYour substance is constantly profitable with theme and gives a heap of information without exertion.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This blog is so nice to me. I will continue to come here again and again. Visit my link as well. Good luck
    obat aborsi
    cara menggugurkan kandungan

    ReplyDelete
  10. This article was very informative, thanks for posting it.
    numpangpromo

    ReplyDelete
  11. The blog or and best that is extremely useful to keep I can share the ideas of the future as this is really what I was looking for, I am very comfortable and pleased to come here. Thank you very much. slope

    ReplyDelete
  12. Interesting post. I Have Been wondering about this issue, so thanks for posting. Pretty cool post.It 's really very nice and Useful post.Thanks
    Massage Therapy Programs

    ReplyDelete
  13. This post is great becasue of chaplains decisions most alone this post is fab and thanks for author share with us.
    Thanks and Regards
    Order Lovegra Online

    ReplyDelete
  14. Enormous website along with attractive and exclusive materials whatever you need.
    24 hour clinic near me

    ReplyDelete
  15. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  16. This post is wonderful and Thanks for sharing this post.Buy Generic Viagra
    Thanks and Regards

    ReplyDelete
  17. Hi! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a team of volunteers and new initiatives in the same niche. Blog gave us useful information to work. You have done an amazing job! Jawahar Thomas

    ReplyDelete
  18. Wonderful illustrated information. I thank you about that. No doubt it will be very useful for my future projects. Would like to see some other posts on the same subject! http://fifa15coinsjoy.com

    ReplyDelete
  19. It is always difficult to make a right decision when you are lonely fighting with the ED. But we have a medical solution for that and known as Viagra Generic 100 mg and it is effective and useful to remove ED.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Loan specialists will factor in this estimation to decide the amount of that esteem they will loan in real money. Most moneylenders will offer from 25 to 50 percent of the estimation of the vehicle. auto title loans chicago

    ReplyDelete
  21. Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful! boston seo

    ReplyDelete
  22. You know your projects stand out of the herd. There is something special about them. It seems to me all of them are really brilliant! 5000 loan no credit check

    ReplyDelete
  23. Dr Itua cure my HIV, I have been a ARV Consumption for 10 years. i have been in pains until i came across Dr Itua on blogs site.I emailed him about my details of my HIV and my location i explained every thing to him and he told me that there is nothing to be scared of that he will cured me, he gave me guarantee,He ask me to pay for items fees so when i'm cured I will show gratitude I did and giving testimony of his healing herbs is what I'm going to do for the rest of you out there having HIV and other disease can see the good work of Dr Itua.I received his herbal medicine through EMS Courier service who delivered to my post office within 5 working days.Dr Itua is an honest man and I appreciate him for his good work.My GrandMa called him to appreciate him and rest of my friends did too,Is a joy to me that I'm free of taking Pills and having that fat belle is a nightmare.you will understand what i'm talking about if you have same problem I was having then not now though.I'm free and healthy Big Thanks To Dr Itua Herbal Center.I have his calendar too that he recently sent me,He Cure all kind disease Like,Cancer,Herpes,Hiv,Hepatitis B,Fibroid,Diabetes,Dercum,Copd ,and also Bring back Ex Lover Back..Here his Contact .drituaherbalcenter@gmail.com Or Whats_app Number +2348149277967

    ReplyDelete
  24. Private health plan's and cash plan's are becoming more and more popular in recent times and are seen as extremely attractive when offered as part of a corporate scheme. Get More Information

    ReplyDelete
  25. Clenbuterol 40mcg 60tabs was a popular steroid used for asthma treatment in the 90s but today there are different drugs for this treatment. clenbuterol for sale online

    ReplyDelete
  26. We also have uniquely designed tools that expedite the process making it safer as well. This, however, hasn't always been the case. Dental handpieces

    ReplyDelete
  27. This is a great article thanks for sharing this informative information. I will visit your blog regularly for some latest post. I will visit your blog regularly for Some latest post. https://www.thenaturalremediesfordiabetes.com/?s=best+walking+shoes&post_type=post

    ReplyDelete
  28. This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post. Teeth whitening machine

    ReplyDelete
  29. Irrespective of receiving daily oral or future injectable depot therapies, these require health care visits for medication and monitoring of safety and response. If patients are treated early enough, before a lot of immune system damage has occurred, life expectancy is close to normal, as long as they remain on successful treatment. However, when patients stop therapy, virus rebounds to high levels in most patients, sometimes associated with severe illness because i have gone through this and even an increased risk of death. The aim of “cure”is ongoing but i still do believe my government made millions of ARV drugs instead of finding a cure. for ongoing therapy and monitoring. ARV alone cannot cure HIV as among the cells that are infected are very long-living CD4 memory cells and possibly other cells that act as long-term reservoirs. HIV can hide in these cells without being detected by the body’s immune system. Therefore even when ART completely blocks subsequent rounds of infection of cells, reservoirs that have been infected before therapy initiation persist and from these reservoirs HIV rebounds if therapy is stopped. “Cure” could either mean an eradication cure, which means to completely rid the body of reservoir virus or a functional HIV cure, where HIV may remain in reservoir cells but rebound to high levels is prevented after therapy interruption.Dr Itua Herbal Medicine makes me believes there is a hope for people suffering from,Cancer,Hiv_ Aids,Herpes,Copd,Diabetes,Hepatitis,I read about him online how he cure Tasha and Tara so i contacted him on drituaherbalcenter@gmail.com even talked on whatsapps +2348149277967 believe me it was easy i drank his herbal medicine for two weeks and i was cured just like that isn't Dr Itua a wonder man? Yes he is! I thank him so much so i will advise if you are suffering from one of those diseases Pls do contact him he's a nice man.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Two full thumbs up for this magnificent article of yours. I've truly delighted in perusing this article today and I figure this may be outstanding amongst other article that I've perused yet. It would be ideal if you keep this work going ahead in a similar quality.
    - 2 player games

    ReplyDelete
  31. Just pure classic stuff from you here. I have never seen such a brilliantly written article in a long time. I am thankful to you that you produced this! lecithin

    ReplyDelete
  32. Your website is really cool and this is a great inspiring article. click here

    ReplyDelete
  33. Its like you read my mind! You seem to know so much about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you can do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but instead of that, this is magnificent blog. An excellent read. I will certainly be back. Elia & Ponto

    ReplyDelete
  34. I simply couldn’t go away your website before suggesting that I actually enjoyed the standard information an individual provide on your visitors? Is gonna be back frequently in order to inspect new posts. https://www.gpwlaw-mi.com/

    ReplyDelete
  35. You have shared the best blog. This is what I really need immediately.
    Conceiveeasy

    ReplyDelete
  36. Provided blogs and articles looking very supportive for us.
    Conceiveeasy

    ReplyDelete
  37. There are many benefits and uses to this type of medical treatment. Website

    ReplyDelete
  38. Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include.
    cannabis store

    ReplyDelete
  39. I couldn't find any knowledge on this matter prior to.Also operate a site and if you are ever interested in doing some. https://asbestoscancer.org/stage-four-mesothelioma/

    ReplyDelete
  40. Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this how to make money online
    posting? I'm pleased I discovered it though, ill be checking back soon to find out what additional posts you include.

    ReplyDelete
  41. The dragonfruit is a goldmine when it comes to nutritional value. strawberry smoothie recipe without yogurt

    ReplyDelete
  42. Your website is terribly informative and your articles are wonderful.31 7 clinic near me

    ReplyDelete
  43. Social communities are all around you and the chances are very good that you are a part of at least a few online social communities for your business.profile

    ReplyDelete
  44. Your blogs and every other content are thus interesting and helpful it makes me return back again.walk in clinic

    ReplyDelete
  45. The blog is a limelight for people.The more I read, the more I fell deep into it.
    Fortress Bio

    ReplyDelete